How would you rate GameFly?
grey star
grey star
grey star
grey star
grey star
New York
6 reviews
17 helpful votes
Follow Gene K.
Unfollow Gene K.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

This website is nice! I can rent video games and movies for not too much. I love their promotions that if you haven't used their services for a while now, you can sign up for real cheap. I can use this service to try out games before buying them (if they don't have an online demo).

However, it can take a while for the disc to get here in NYC after being shipped. If you don't receive it after seven days, you can report it as lost and they can send in another of the same game or something else on your queue. Sometimes the discs DO genuinely go missing. Also, the self-return thing is quite nice. Even if you won't send back the game on the same day, you can use this thing. They must receive the disc fourteen days after you mark it as self-return. This gives you time to play it some more. After you do mark it as self-returned, they will send you the next disc when they ship it out next.

I took off a star because the shipping can take too long and that the service at regular price is a tad too expensive for me.

Date of experience: January 10, 2025
Indiana
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Jason G.
Unfollow Jason G.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

I tried to buy something because of how cheap the games were and I got an email stating that I needed to go through all this red tape to verify my purchase, and have my credit card company call them, but I didn't use a credit card. Customer support is terrible, just pay the extra $5.00 and buy from ebay or gamestop, hard lesson learned.

Date of experience: November 13, 2021
Indiana
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Jesse C.
Unfollow Jesse C.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

So not only does this service falsely advertise for free shipping, it's free shipping is locked to the rental service so if you want to buy anything expect a 20$ shipping fee. On top of that they don't take your order seriously whatsoever. 24-48 hours to ship the product not counting the time it takes to get to the shipping facility. They advertise their shipping as priority but the only priority they have is getting you to subscribe to their inefficient mail in service. I wouldnt recommend buying or renting anything from this site.

Date of experience: June 10, 2022
North Carolina
2 reviews
0 helpful votes
Follow C L.
Unfollow C L.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Awful
November 4, 2022

This place is terrible, your games spend more time in transit and waiting for game-locked games to re-game-lock because they were taken off by the site. Now my account is sitting idle and I'm paying for not having games when I had game-locked games available. PlayStation has a similar model and it's way better for the money and time. What a shame.

Date of experience: November 4, 2022
New Jersey
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow D M.
Unfollow D M.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Was told my purchase was under review but they did not specify which purchase. Asked questions that weren't answered, like which order was an issue, and was not offered any help. Only received copy and paste answers. When I had a chance to call in to verify this order, I was placed on hold and then hung up on almost 10 minutes later. Worst customer service experience. Why do I have to jump through hoops to give a company my money. Will not be dealing with GameFly ever again.

Date of experience: October 6, 2022
Kansas
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Dale Q.
Unfollow Dale Q.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Terrible
February 12, 2024

They only got one star cause it made me. They deserve no stars. Started a free trial for 30 days after cancelling years ago took almost 8 days to get my first game. Kept that for a couple weeks it's been in the mail for 8 days and they still have not got it (witch I know is a USPS problem) there shipping partners are destroying the good thing. I also seen some ads of gameflys on facebook so I was telling people the way it really works not the crap some random worker posts and got blocked. So all in all gamefly is not worth any amount of money waiting for them to get my game so I can cancel cause they will charge you if they don't have game and you cancel.

Date of experience: February 12, 2024
California
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Ace D.
Unfollow Ace D.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

I locked a game to guarantee I received it when it comes out. How it works is you have to return a game before the new game comes out so they can ensure it can be sent to you. However the last time I sent a game back it took them over four days to confirm it with fast return only for it to fall into the time period of the locked game and now I've received no game until the new game comes out a week from then and of course three days after the game had came out already I had still not received it. I pay almost $30 for two games at a time and always have problems with the return even with fast return and game lock only ensures that I don't have a game for 1/3 of the month. The poor service and bad business would have ended them a long time ago if they had any rival in their industry.

Date of experience: October 16, 2023
Michigan
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Matthew W.
Unfollow Matthew W.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Shipping sucks
August 24, 2023

I returned a game and a week later they still have not shipped anything to me. The answer I received is they are to busy to ship me one. But not to busy to keep taking payment for a service I am not receiving. The customer service sucks. Considering the customer service person agree with me that they have horrible service. Don't waste your times

Date of experience: August 24, 2023
California
5 reviews
0 helpful votes
Follow Jana D.
Unfollow Jana D.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Reasonable prices
October 6, 2021

This is my 2nd time using Gamefly and I think it is great. I have had no problems receiving games for Playstation 5 and Xbox Series X. I really like this agency, I thing their prices are reasonable. I will be using them for a long time!

Date of experience: October 6, 2021
California
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow The T.
Unfollow The T.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

These people are outright thieves and con artists. I am an online seller who makes a living shipping out 100 or more packages a week. For almost two years I have played whack a mole with this company. I considered it a success if a game arrived in 10 days. They are coming from one state away so it should arrive in two days via first class mail. I KNOW how long it takes. All too often they never arrive and I have to report them lost. Or I send them out amongst my other packages and gamefly claims they never arrive. Yet ALL of the packages I send and receive through my business arrive as expected. They seem quick to accept my report of them not arriving and always send another game (at least 15 times this has happened). Which tells me they KNOW what they are doing. When you are setup for 2 rentals and you spend 3 weeks per month dealing with the "loss" of a disc, it is just too much. These people hate their customers. Do NOT use them. If you do after reading this, you deserve what you get. You would think considering all games are turning toward online downloads, they would be fighting to stay relevant by taking care of their customers. They act as though they are supporters of abandoning discs and want to make using discs as miserable as possible. It's quite strange actually.

Date of experience: February 19, 2024

Overview

GameFly has a rating of 2.8 stars from 73 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally dissatisfied with their purchases. Reviewers dissatisfied with GameFly most frequently mention and customer service. GameFly ranks 2nd among Retro Video Games sites.

service
22
value
20
shipping
19
returns
17
quality
20